Foil pans are the quiet heroes of the American potluck. Nobody wants to chase a borrowed casserole dish, and nobody wants to soak a roasting pan after a holiday. A disposable pan solves both, and it is often how tamales, carnitas and enchiladas travel from one kitchen to a family party.
The hard part of buying them on Amazon is the packs. Most listings offer 30, 50 or more, which is a restaurant quantity. This guide sorts pans by size and by job, sticks to packs a home cupboard can hold, and gives only the sizes the makers state.
Julia’s earns a commission on purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Recommendations are based on what a restaurant kitchen looks for, product specifications, maker statements and named reviews where we could read them.
Quick verdict: which foil pans to buy
For most home cooks, buy the Glad half-size deep pans: at 12.5 by 10.25 by 2.5 inches, they fit a standard tray of enchiladas, and they come in a two-pack. For a big roast or a crowd, get the Glad full-size pan, once you have measured your oven. If you bake to give away, the Stock Your Home 8-by-8 pans come with lids.
Sizes vary a little between brands even when two pans are both called half size. If a recipe or a chafing rack depends on an exact fit, read the stated dimensions in the listing.
Five foil pans at a glance
Five picks by job. All seven are reviewed below.
| Foil pan | Best for | Stated size | Count | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Glad Half Size Deep Foil Pans, 2 ctBest overall
|
Enchiladas, casseroles, potlucks | 12.5 x 10.25 x 2.5 in | 2 | View on Amazon |
Glad Full Size Deep Foil Pans, 2 ctBest for roasting
|
Turkey, big batches, buffet service | 20.5 x 12.5 x 2.75 in | 2 | View on Amazon |
Nicole Home Collection Half Size Foil Pans, 10 packBest small bulk pack
|
Regular hosts, meal prep | 10 x 12.75 x 2.5 in | 10 | View on Amazon |
Stock Your Home 8 x 8 Foil Pans with Lids, 10 packBest with lids
|
Brownies, freezer meals, gifts | 8 x 8 x 2 in | 10, with lids | View on Amazon |
Hefty EZ Foil Extra Large Pie Pans, 12 packBest pie pan
|
Pies for giving away | 9 11/16 in x 1 1/3 in | 12 | View on Amazon |
Sizes and counts come from each listing. Prices change, so check them on Amazon.
Our picks for the best foil pans
All of these were in stock as new items when we checked. Branded roasters were the gap: most Handi-Foil and Reynolds roasting pans were out of stock, so the Glad full-size pan is our roasting answer.
1. Glad Half Size Deep Foil Pans, 2 ct – The Potluck Workhorse
If you buy one foil pan for a home kitchen, this is the size. The half-size deep pan is what most of us mean when we say a nine-by-thirteen foil pan, and it holds a full tray of enchiladas, a pan of mac and cheese or a small roast. Glad lists it at 12.5 by 10.25 by 2.5 inches, and the deep sides are there to keep sauce and drippings from running.
Glad says it is safe for freezer storage and suitable for baking, grilling, roasting and reheating. It also suggests rinsing and reusing when possible. The two-count pack is a sensible home quantity. Many deep half-size pans on Amazon come in packs of 30, which is more than many of us will use in years, and they take up a surprising amount of cupboard room.
Like any foil pan, it will flex when full. Carry it on a sheet pan, not by the rim.
Why we like it
- 2.5-inch depth keeps sauce in
- Two-count pack suits one meal
- Freezer safe, per Glad
- Sold by Amazon when we checked
Key specifications
| Model | BB19935 |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 12.5 x 10.25 x 2.5 in |
| Count | 2 |
| Shape | Half-size deep rectangle |
| Lid | Not included |
| Freezer safe | Yes, per Glad |
| Reuse | Rinse and reuse when possible, per Glad |
| Stated material notes | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits the cook who takes a dish to a potluck a few times a year and wants no pan to bring home.
Skip it if you host big parties often, since a larger pack will work out better.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Right size for most recipes
- Small pack
- Deep sides
Cons
- No lid; cover with foil
- Flexes when full, so it needs support
2. Glad Full Size Deep Foil Pans, 2 ct – Large Enough for a Crowd
This is the big pan, at 20.5 by 12.5 by 2.75 inches, and a good answer to disposable aluminum roasting pans now that many branded roasters are out of stock. Glad lists baking, roasting and reheating, and it adds that the pan can sit on a bottom rack to catch drips. The sides are ribbed, with a rolled rim.
Measure your oven first. A 20.5-inch pan is built for the food-service steam table, and while it will fit many full-size home ovens, it will not fit all of them, and it will not fit a toaster oven or most apartment-size ranges. It also leaves little room for air around the sides, so you may need to rotate it.
Glad says each full pan fits two of its half-size pans, which is useful if you want to hold warm water below a smaller pan on a buffet line.
Why we like it
- 20.5 inches holds a large bird or a big batch
- Ribbed sides and rolled rim
- Two-count pack
- Holds two half-size pans, per Glad
Key specifications
| Model | BB21178 |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 20.5 x 12.5 x 2.75 in |
| Count | 2 |
| Shape | Full-size deep rectangle |
| Lid | Not included |
| Freezer safe | Yes, per Glad |
| Reuse | Rinse and reuse when possible, per Glad |
| Stated material notes | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits a holiday roast or a big gathering, where you need one large pan and no washing up.
Skip it if your oven is narrow. Measure inside the oven before you buy.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Big capacity
- Small home pack
- Fits half-size pans for buffets
Cons
- May not fit smaller ovens
- Needs two hands and support when full
3. Nicole Home Collection Half Size Foil Pans, 10 pack – A Reasonable Larger Pack
If you use foil pans more than a couple of times a year, a two-pack starts to feel silly. This ten-pack is the same general half-size shape, at 10 by 12.75 by 2.5 inches, from a brand owned by King Zak Industries, the seller on the listing. The listing describes high-grade thick aluminum with reinforced walls, and says the pans go in the freezer, broiler and grill.
It also says you can wash them in the dishwasher, which is an unusual thing to hear about a foil pan. We would hand wash them gently, since the thin metal can dent or dull. The listing’s other claims, such as superior heat conductivity, are general marketing, so we would not read much into them.
We looked for an independent review of foil pans and found none worth citing, so this rests on the listing alone.
Why we like it
- Ten pans cover a season of cooking
- Grill, broiler and freezer use named
- Same half-size shape as the Glad
- Reasonable pack for a home cupboard
Key specifications
| Model | 08611 |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 10 x 12.75 x 2.5 in |
| Count | 10 |
| Shape | Half-size deep rectangle |
| Lid | Not included in this pack |
| Freezer safe | Yes, per listing |
| Reuse | Dishwasher wash claimed, per listing |
| Stated material notes | Recyclable, per listing |
Why we recommend it
It suits someone who batches freezer meals or hosts often, without buying a catering carton.
Skip it if you need only one or two pans, or you want a lid included.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Good count for regular use
- Depth holds saucy food
- Named for several uses
Cons
- Rests on listing claims alone
- No lids in this pack
4. Stock Your Home 8 x 8 Foil Pans with Lids, 10 pack – Small Pans, Lids Included
An 8-by-8 pan is the size for brownies, a small lasagna or a cornbread, and a set with lids is the size for taking food to someone else’s house. This pack holds 10 pans and 10 lids, each pan listed at 8 by 8 by 2 inches. If you make freezer meals for a new parent or an older relative, this is the pack you want: no one has to return the dish.
The listing says the pans work in conventional and toaster ovens, and that they suit baking, storing and prepping food. The excerpt of the listing we read does not say what the lids are made of. Take them off for the oven unless the package says otherwise, and check the label when you open it.
Stock Your Home is one of the online-first brands, and we limit those on a page. We chose it for the size and the lids.
Why we like it
- Lids included for each pan
- 8 x 8 suits small recipes
- Works in a toaster oven, per the listing
- Pack of 10 is manageable
Key specifications
| Model | 2270 |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 8 x 8 x 2 in |
| Count | 10 |
| Shape | Square |
| Lid | Included; material not stated in the text we read |
| Freezer safe | Not stated |
| Reuse | Disposable; recyclable, per listing |
| Stated material notes | Recyclable, per listing |
Why we recommend it
It suits anyone who bakes to give away, stocks a freezer or cooks for one or two.
Skip it if you need something deep, since 2 inches is shallow for a lasagna with extra layers.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Lids included
- Toaster oven use named
- Useful small size
Cons
- Shallow for deep bakes
- Lid material not clear in the listing text
5. Stock Your Home Mini Loaf Pans with Lids, 1 lb, 30 Pack – Banana Bread to Give
Foil loaf pans make banana bread into a gift without giving away a pan. These 1-pound mini pans from Stock Your Home come with clear plastic dome lids. The listing gives the pan as 6 inches long at the top, 3.5 inches wide and 2 inches high, so one recipe makes several small loaves.
The listing says the pans are freezer and oven safe, but the lids are not oven safe, so take them off before you bake and snap them on once the loaf is cool. This is a pack of 30, more than a small baking session needs, and the size is a mini loaf rather than a full 2-pound pan.
Why we like it
- Lids included
- Clear dome lids show the loaf
- Stated dimensions on the listing
- Freezer and oven safe pans, per the listing
Key specifications
| Model | Not stated |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 1 lb; 6 x 3.5 x 2 in |
| Count | 30 pans, 30 lids |
| Shape | Mini loaf |
| Lid | Clear plastic dome; not oven safe |
| Freezer safe | Yes, per listing |
| Reuse | Disposable |
| Stated material notes | Aluminum foil |
Why we recommend it
It suits a holiday baker or anyone who gives quick breads away.
Skip it if you want a full-size 2-pound loaf, or only need a few pans.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Gift-ready with lids
- Clear stated dimensions
- Enough for a season of baking
Cons
- Mini size, not a full loaf
- Lids must come off in the oven
- Big pack for occasional bakers
6. Hefty EZ Foil Extra Large Pie Pans, 12 pack – For Deep Holiday Pies
A foil pie pan means a pie can travel without anyone having to remember whose dish it was. Hefty’s EZ Foil line is one of the better-known names here, and this listing is for a pack of 12 extra-large round pans, 9 11/16 inches across and 1 1/3 inches deep, sized for 10-inch recipes.
There is little else in the listing, which is short. Foil pans are thin, so check your pie early and bake on a sheet pan for support. That also catches any filling that bubbles over. Note that the seller here was a third party rather than Amazon.
Why we like it
- Sized for 10-inch recipes, per the listing
- Pack of 12 for holiday baking
- Well-known EZ Foil line
- Easy to give away
Key specifications
| Model | 90810 |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 9 11/16 in x 1 1/3 in deep |
| Count | 12 |
| Shape | Round |
| Lid | Not included |
| Freezer safe | Not stated |
| Reuse | Disposable |
| Stated material notes | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits a holiday pie baker, or anyone who sends pies home with guests.
Skip it if you bake pies only now and then, since 12 is a lot of pans to store.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Clear size stated
- Good count for a season
- Recognized maker line
Cons
- Very short listing
- Third-party seller when we checked
7. Durable Packaging 5 3/4 in Pot Pie Pans with Lids, 25 pack – Single-Serve Portions
For individual portions, a small round pan with a lid is hard to beat. This listing covers 25 pans at 5 3/4 inches across, extra deep, with clear snap-on lids. It suits pot pies, single portions of mole or chili for the freezer, or a make-ahead dinner for someone living alone. The listing gives a stated 30-gauge foil, which is more detail than most foil pan listings offer.
The listing calls the pans oven safe, but the clear plastic lids are another matter: take them off before the pan goes in the oven. The brand on this listing is Durable Packaging, while the text and the seller are KitchenDance, so ask the seller if you want to know exactly who makes it. Twenty-five is more than a one-time need, but a small stack does not take much room.
Why we like it
- Stated 30-gauge foil
- Clear lids snap on
- Single-serve size
- Extra-deep for pot pies
Key specifications
| Model | 2400P |
|---|---|
| Stated size | 5 3/4 in round, extra deep |
| Count | 25 |
| Shape | Round |
| Lid | Included, clear plastic |
| Freezer safe | Not stated |
| Reuse | Disposable; recyclable, per listing |
| Stated material notes | Recyclable and kosher certified, per listing |
Why we recommend it
It suits meal prep for one, batch cooking or small pot pies.
Skip it if you want to bake with the lid on, since it is plastic and must come off first.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Stated gauge
- Lids make freezer stacking easy
- Useful portion size
Cons
- Brand and listing text name different companies
- Plastic lid must come off for baking
How to choose disposable aluminum roasting pans and bakers
Five checks before you buy.
- Measure the oven. A 20-inch pan needs a full-size oven. Measure inside the oven, not the door.
- Depth. Two and a half inches is the safe depth for saucy food. Two inches or less suits brownies and sheet cakes.
- Support. Foil flexes. Carry a full pan on a sheet pan, and do not try to lift a roast by the rim alone.
- Lids. Lids make a pan easy to stack in the freezer. Clear plastic lids come off before baking, and foil is a fine cover for the oven.
- Acidic food. Reynolds says of its foil that small pinholes or discoloration may occur with highly acidic, spicy or salty foods, and calls the reaction harmless. A strong salsa or a tomato sauce stored for days is worth moving into a glass container.
How we picked these seven pans
We started with Amazon listings, keeping only pans that were plainly in stock, new, sold in home-sized packs and from identifiable makers. A web search for an independent review of foil pans turned up retail pages and thin blogs, and no review we would rely on. So these picks rest on the listing and maker details, not on a test, and nobody at Julia’s has cooked in these particular pans.
We left out pans sold as restaurant cases, and listings with very thin data, such as a Hefty roaster listing whose package weight suggests a case rather than a single pan. A few sellers here are third parties, and we name those on the picks.
Foil pan questions, answered
What size is a half-size foil pan?
Roughly 10 by 12 inches on top, the common size for a nine-by-thirteen recipe. Glad’s half-size is 12.5 by 10.25 by 2.5 inches, and Nicole Home Collection’s is 10 by 12.75 by 2.5 inches.
Can you roast a turkey in a foil pan?
Many people do, but the pan must be supported. Set it on a sheet pan or rack, and do not carry it by the rim. Glad lists roasting for both its half-size and full-size pans. For a pan you will reuse for years, see the best roasting pan.
Can foil pans go in the freezer?
Glad says yes, with a foil cover, and Nicole Home Collection’s listing says they are freezer safe. Wrap the top well, label the pan and thaw it in the refrigerator.
Can you reuse foil pans?
Glad suggests rinsing and reusing when possible. Nicole Home Collection’s listing even says you can use the dishwasher, though we would hand wash gently. Once a pan is dented or scratched, recycle it where your local program takes clean foil.
Can foil pans go on the grill?
Nicole Home Collection and Glad list grilling. Keep it over moderate heat, and watch for the pan warping when full.
Our final pick for the next potluck
Keep a pair of Glad half-size pans in the cupboard, and buy larger packs only if you really use them. For a dish you will keep, see the best baking dishes. For the rest of the party, see our taco bar supplies guide, and the best baking sheets covers the sheet pan that should go under every full foil pan.
And if you would rather let someone else cook tonight, see the menu or call to order.