An ice pick is one of the plainest tools you can own: a steel point in a handle. It breaks a block of clear ice into cocktail-sized pieces, frees up a frozen bag, and shaves a big cube down to fit a glass.
The differences that matter are small but practical. How many points does it have, how does it store safely, and does the handle stay in your hand when it’s cold and wet? These tools are sharp by design, so a guard or sheath counts for a lot in a kitchen drawer. Keep them away from children.
Julia’s earns a commission on purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. We have not used these products ourselves. Recommendations rest on maker and listing details, and we name the sources we read.
Quick verdict: which ice pick to buy
Buy the Barfly Ice Pick for most home bars: cast stainless steel with a rubberized grip, from Mercer’s bar line. If you want a sheath and a wood handle, the True Spike is the one to get. For a tool with a spring guard and a crusher end, look at the Japanese-made Kotobuki, and for breaking up large blocks, the three-point Outset.
Five ice picks side by side
The five that cover most home bars, one for each kind of buyer.
| Pick | Best for | Type | Safety | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Barfly Ice PickBest overall
|
Everyday bar use | Single point | Not stated | View on Amazon |
True Spike Ice PickBest with a sheath
|
Drawer storage | Single point | Sheath included | View on Amazon |
Kotobuki Ice Pick With Spring GuardBest guarded
|
Guarded storage | Single point, crusher end | Spring guard | View on Amazon |
Outset Three-Prong Ice PickBest three-prong
|
Shaping and splitting blocks | Three prongs | Not stated | View on Amazon |
Winco Six-Prong Ice ChipperBest for fast chipping
|
Fast chipping | Six prongs | Not stated | View on Amazon |
Our picks for the best ice pick
1. Barfly Ice Pick – Heavy Stainless With a Sure Grip
Barfly is the bar-tool line from Mercer Culinary, a familiar name in restaurant kitchens. This pick is listed as ultra heavy-duty cast stainless steel with a hardened blade, and a rubberized handle, which is the useful choice when your hands are wet and cold. About 8 inches overall, it’s meant for chipping and scoring ice.
Hand wash it with mild soap and warm water, Barfly says, and avoid detergents with bleach or heavy chlorination. The listing doesn’t mention a guard, so plan on a safe place to keep the point. A knife block slot or a cork pushed on the tip both work.
Why we like it
- Cast stainless steel, per the listing.
- Rubberized handle for a wet grip.
- Sold and shipped by Amazon.
- Named maker with a bar and restaurant range.
Key specifications
| Model | M37074 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Stainless steel |
| Length | About 8 in |
| Type | Single point |
| Guard or sheath | Not stated |
| Handle | Rubberized |
| Care | Hand wash |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
This suits a home bartender who chips ice regularly and wants a solid tool that won’t slip. The grip is the deciding point over wood.
Skip it if you need a guard in the box, or you prefer the look of wood on a bar cart.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Solid all-stainless working end
- Grip suited to wet hands
- Clear care guidance
Cons
- No sheath mentioned
- Black rubber grip won’t suit every bar
- No independent test found
2. True Spike Ice Pick – A Wood Handle and a Safety Cover
True makes bar tools and wine gear, and this 8.5-inch pick pairs a stainless steel shaft with a wood handle and a cover for the point. That cover is why it’s here: most drawers aren’t a safe place for a bare spike.
The listing says it comes with a sheath and calls the grip non-slip. No warranty, the listing says plainly. The lead seller when we checked was a third party, Segunda Vida by Twine, listing it as new.
Why we like it
- Sheath included for storage.
- Stainless steel shaft, per the listing.
- Wood handle, 8.5 inches overall.
Key specifications
| Model | 3148 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Stainless steel |
| Length | 8.5 in |
| Type | Single point |
| Guard or sheath | Sheath |
| Handle | Wood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
A good match for anyone keeping a pick in a shared drawer, or taking one along on a trip with a cooler.
Skip it if you want a stated warranty, or a wet grip you can count on. Wood can get slick.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Point is covered in storage
- Classic look
- Comfortable length
Cons
- No warranty
- Care not stated
- Third-party lead seller
3. Kotobuki Ice Pick With Spring Guard – Spring Guard and a Crusher End
Kotobuki is a Japanese housewares brand, and this short pick has two ideas we like. A spring guard covers the point until you press it onto the ice, and the butt of the handle works as a crusher for cracking smaller pieces.
The listing is brief: stainless steel, black wood grip, made in Japan. It’s about 5.25 inches, which is short for big blocks but handy for working on a single large cube over a glass.
Why we like it
- Spring guard covers the point.
- Crusher on the butt of the handle.
- Made in Japan, the listing states.
Key specifications
| Model | 450-053 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Stainless steel |
| Length | About 5.25 in |
| Type | Single point, crusher end |
| Guard or sheath | Spring guard |
| Handle | Black wood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Japan |
Why we recommend it
This is for the careful buyer who wants the point covered at all times, and anyone who works on one cube at a time.
Skip it if you need reach for a big block. This is the shortest pick here.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Guard is built in, so it can’t get lost
- Two tools in one
- Made in Japan
Cons
- Short for big blocks
- Thin listing
- Third-party seller
4. Outset Three-Prong Ice Pick – Three Points to Split a Block
A three-pronged pick spreads the force across several points, so a block tends to split where you ask it to and not skid away. Outset’s version has metal tips in a curved beechwood handle, and it measures 7.25 by 1.5 by 1 inches.
The maker says to use it to shape, split and crush ice, and to wash it by hand in warm soapy water, not in the dishwasher. There’s no guard, so three points need extra care in a drawer.
Why we like it
- Three prongs for splitting and shaping.
- Curved beechwood handle.
- Clear hand-wash instructions.
Key specifications
| Model | 66800 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Metal, type not stated |
| Length | 7.25 in |
| Type | Three prongs |
| Guard or sheath | Not stated |
| Handle | Beechwood |
| Care | Hand wash |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
Choose it if you freeze your own clear ice in a block and want to cut it into pieces.
Skip it if you only need to free up frozen cubes or score a line. A single point is more precise.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Good for block work
- Comfortable curved handle
- Sold and shipped by Amazon
Cons
- No guard
- Metal type not stated
- Three points are harder to store
5. Winco Six-Prong Ice Chipper – Six Points for Quick Chipping
Winco sells restaurant supplies, and this chipper is really a different tool from a single pick: six prongs on a nickeled steel head, 9 inches long and about 2.5 inches wide, with a wooden handle. It takes large pieces down quickly, at the cost of any precision.
The listing says it suits commercial kitchens and residential bars. It’s worth noting the head is nickeled steel, not stainless, so dry it well after use.
Why we like it
- Six prongs chip a lot of ice quickly.
- Nickeled head is listed as rust resistant.
- Wood handle for a comfortable grip.
- Sold and shipped by Amazon.
Key specifications
| Model | ICH-9 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Nickeled steel |
| Length | 9 in |
| Type | Six prongs |
| Guard or sheath | Not stated |
| Handle | Wood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
Handy for filling a cooler or tub from a big bag that has frozen solid. Think parties, not single cocktails.
Skip it if you carve cocktail ice. It’s too wide for careful work.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Quick on big volumes
- Restaurant-supply maker
- Long reach
Cons
- No precision
- No guard
- Plated, not stainless
6. Cocktail Kingdom Anvil Ice Pick – From a Dedicated Bar-Tool Maker
Cocktail Kingdom is a specialist in bar tools, and its Anvil pick is sold on Amazon by the company itself in wood and stainless steel. The listing says almost nothing else beyond “score ice”, so we can’t give you a length or care guidance from it.
We include it because the maker is a real bar specialist and it’s sold directly. Check the size in the product photos before you buy, and treat the lack of detail as the drawback it is.
Why we like it
- Sold directly by Cocktail Kingdom.
- Wood handle and stainless steel.
- Meant for scoring ice, the listing says.
Key specifications
| Model | Not stated |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Stainless steel |
| Length | Not stated |
| Type | Single point |
| Guard or sheath | Not stated |
| Handle | Wood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
For someone building a bar kit from one specialist maker, with matching pieces in mind.
Skip it if you want to know exact dimensions before buying. This listing doesn’t give them.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Specialist maker
- Direct seller
- Simple materials
Cons
- Very thin listing
- No stated size
- No guard mentioned
7. Norpro Stainless Ice Pick – A Plain Pick With a Sheath
Norpro is a long-running kitchen gadget brand, and this is the plain version of the tool: 7.25 inches, stainless steel, wood handle and a sheath, by the listing’s title. The title also names party and camping use, which fits a small pick with a cover.
That title is nearly all the listing offers, so there’s no care or warranty information to go on. Norpro’s other picks were low in stock when we checked, which is why we chose this listing.
Why we like it
- Sheath named in the listing title.
- Stainless steel with wood handle.
- Compact for a cooler or bar bag.
Key specifications
| Model | Not stated |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Stainless steel |
| Length | 7.25 in |
| Type | Single point |
| Guard or sheath | Sheath |
| Handle | Wood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
A fair choice if you just want a covered pick for occasional use, and you know the brand.
Skip it if you want details before you buy, or a seller other than a small third party.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Covered point
- Handy size
- Familiar kitchen brand
Cons
- Almost no listing detail
- Third-party seller
- No care guidance
8. New Star Foodservice Carbon Steel Ice Pick – A Foodservice Pick in Carbon Steel
New Star supplies restaurants, and this 7.5-inch pick uses carbon steel and a hardwood handle. The listing calls it suited to homes as well as bars and restaurants, and it’s sold by New Star itself.
Carbon steel is the catch. It isn’t stainless, so we’d dry it right after use to stop rust. For a tool that spends its working life on melting ice, that’s a real chore, and most home users should choose stainless unless they want this particular feel.
Why we like it
- Carbon steel for strength, per the listing.
- Hardwood handle.
- Sold directly by the maker.
Key specifications
| Model | 48353 |
|---|---|
| Tip material | Carbon steel |
| Length | 7.5 in |
| Type | Single point |
| Guard or sheath | Not stated |
| Handle | Hardwood |
| Care | Not stated |
| Made in | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
Fits a buyer who looks after carbon steel knives already and won’t mind one more tool to dry.
Skip it if you’d leave it wet in a sink. Stainless suits that habit better.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Restaurant-supply maker
- Plain, solid design
- Direct seller
Cons
- Carbon steel needs drying
- No guard
- Care not stated
How to choose an ice pick
Number of points
One point gives the most control: you can score a line and split along it. Three prongs split blocks with less skidding. Six prongs chip quickly but roughly. Most home bars need one point, and big-block people add a three-prong.
Storage and safety
This matters more than the steel. A sheath or spring guard keeps fingers safe in a drawer. Of our picks, True and Norpro list a sheath and Kotobuki has a built-in spring guard. For the others, keep the point in a block or stuck into a cork, and always out of the reach of children. Work on a folded towel so the ice can’t skate, and aim away from the hand holding it.
Steel and care
Stainless needs less attention around meltwater. Carbon steel and plated heads should be dried right away. Barfly and Outset both call for hand washing, which we’d do for all of them.
Handle
Wood looks better and rubber grips better when wet. We’d choose on where you’ll use it: over a sink, rubber; on a bar cart, wood.
Length
A longer pick gives you leverage on a big block, while a short one suits a single cube over a glass. The picks here run from about 5.25 to 9 inches.
How we picked these ice picks
We searched Amazon for ice picks and chippers and kept in-stock tools with a new lead offer from makers we could identify. Most of the search results were generic picks from brands we couldn’t place, including several that keep turning up in online lists. We left those out, along with Barfly’s portable pick, Winco’s own single pick and two Norpro listings that were low in stock.
We have not used these tools. A search for independent reviews turned up only affiliate lists and retail listings, which we did not rely on, so no pick here rests on a named review. Everything specific comes from the listing, and where a listing says nothing, we say so. The advice about working on a towel and storing the point is our own common sense and not a maker’s instruction.
Ice pick questions, answered
What is a bar ice pick used for?
Scoring and splitting blocks of clear ice, chipping pieces for a drink and shaping big cubes. If you make your own clear ice in a mold, you may not need one at all.
Can an ice pick damage my freezer?
It can, so we wouldn’t use one to defrost. A sharp point can puncture freezer walls and lines. Follow your freezer maker’s defrosting advice instead.
How do you sharpen an ice pick?
None of these listings gives instructions. If a point gets dull, a knife sharpener or fine stone can help, but we’d replace an inexpensive tool whose tip is bent.
Is stainless better than carbon steel?
For wet work at home, generally yes, since carbon steel rusts if left damp. New Star’s carbon steel pick is here for people happy to dry it each time.
Does it work for a block I freeze at home?
Yes, that’s the main job. Three-prong tools such as the Outset are made for it.
Our final pick for breaking ice at home
The Barfly is the one we’d buy for most bars, and the True Spike if a cover matters more than a grip. Once you have the pieces you want, our ice tongs and ice bucket guides cover the next steps, and our ice ball molds guide helps if you’d rather skip the chipping. For drinks someone else has already iced, see Julia’s drinks or call to order at (346) 546-8283.