Plenty of good cooking depends on keeping two parts of an egg apart. A trace of yolk can stop whites from whipping, and that matters for a meringue, a tres leches sponge or the airy batter on a chile relleno. Passing a yolk back and forth between two sharp halves of shell works, but it also puts the yolk at risk with every pass.
A separator fixes that for very little money and very little drawer space. The catch is that they are not all good. The one real side-by-side report we found says most of them disappointed, so the best egg separator is the one whose design suits the way you actually bake.
Julia’s earns a commission on purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Recommendations are based on what a restaurant kitchen looks for, product specifications and what makers and reviewers state.
Quick verdict: which egg separator to buy
For most homes, the best egg separator is the OXO Good Grips 3-in-1 Egg Separator: it gives you an edge to crack on, grips the bowl and keeps shell out of the batter. For metal, choose the Fox Run Stainless Steel Egg Yolk Separator. To lift yolks out of eggs already in a bowl, choose the Peleg Design YolkFish.
Below are seven separators in plastic, steel and silicone, each with one honest reason to skip it.
Five egg separators side by side
Five standout picks, one for each kind of buyer, with the details each maker or listing states. All seven separators are reviewed in full below.
| Separator | Best for | Style | Fit | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OXO Good Grips 3-in-1 Egg SeparatorBest overall
|
Most home bakers | Clip-on slotted cup | Fits virtually any bowl | View on Amazon |
Chef Craft Basic Plastic Egg SeparatorSimplest choice
|
An occasional recipe | Slotted plastic scoop | 5 in long | View on Amazon |
Fox Run Stainless Steel Egg Yolk SeparatorBest stainless from a known maker
|
Metal over plastic | Stainless steel | 6.75 x 1.75 x 1 in | View on Amazon |
Peleg Design YolkFish Silicone Egg SeparatorBest suction style
|
Eggs already in a bowl | Silicone squeeze fish | Suction, one yolk at a time | View on Amazon |
CAMKYDE Stainless Steel Spiral Egg SeparatorBest for big bowls
|
Wide mixing bowls | Stainless steel coil | Hooks on any bowl size, per the listing | View on Amazon |
Our picks for the best egg separator
Each pick is a tool made to split a raw egg, not a slicer or a piercer. They run from the most useful everyday design to the more specialized ones.
1. OXO Good Grips 3-in-1 Egg Separator – Cracks, Catches and Clips On
This is the separator to buy if you only want one. It does three small jobs that the plain slotted spoons skip. A raised edge gives you a place to crack the egg, the body catches the yolk while the white runs through, and, according to BestReviews, the tool clamps onto a bowl or cup so your hands stay free. OXO says it fits virtually any bowl, and that the design keeps drips from running down the side of the bowl and onto the counter.
The shell is the part most people overlook. A separator that sits over the batter can drop a fragment straight into it. OXO’s listing says this one keeps shells from falling into batters, and BestReviews, which named it Best of the Best, praises the same thing, along with the compact storage.
It is not the fastest tool here. BestReviews says it separates yolks more slowly than other models, and Sous Vide Guy notes that the cup may be small for a large yolk and that you may need to move the yolk around to clear all of the white. For a recipe that needs two or three eggs, that hardly matters. For a dozen whites, it becomes a wait.
Why we like it
- Raised edge for cracking the egg
- Clamps onto a bowl or cup, per BestReviews
- Keeps shell out of the batter, according to OXO
- Dishwasher safe
Key specifications
| Model | 1147780 |
|---|---|
| Material | Not stated on the listing |
| Style | Clip-on slotted cup |
| How it holds | Clamps on a bowl or cup, per BestReviews |
| Size | Not stated |
| Eggs at a time | Not stated |
| Care | Dishwasher safe |
| Guarantee | OXO satisfaction guarantee |
Why we recommend it
It suits the home baker who separates eggs a few times a month and wants the crack, the separation and the shell control handled in one place. OXO also backs it with a satisfaction guarantee.
Skip it if you separate eggs by the dozen. The slower drain will test your patience, and a long coil tool clears whites with less waiting.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Handles cracking and separating in one tool
- Stays on the bowl by itself
- Named top pick by BestReviews
- Stores compactly
Cons
- Slower than other styles, per BestReviews
- The cup can be tight for a large yolk
- The listing does not state material or size
2. Chef Craft Basic Plastic Egg Separator – Simple and Nothing to Learn
Chef Craft makes the old-fashioned version: a small white plastic scoop with slots, 5 inches long. You crack the egg into it, the yolk stays in the bowl of the tool and the white drips through the slots. There are no moving parts and nothing to figure out, and it is about the easiest thing in the drawer to wash.
The listing says it is made of BPA-free plastic and is dishwasher safe, and that it keeps eggshell out of the recipe. It shows no hook and gives no capacity, and at 5 inches it is short, so plan on holding it over a small bowl or a cup and not resting it across a big mixing bowl.
The evidence for this one is modest. Roundups that turned up in our search place it as the plain, basic option, but none of them report anything we would call a careful comparison. We include it because Chef Craft is a long-running housewares maker, the design has little that can go wrong, and it answers a real need: a tool for the two times a year a recipe calls for separated eggs.
Why we like it
- Made of BPA-free plastic, per the listing
- Dishwasher safe
- No parts to lose
- Small enough for any drawer
Key specifications
| Model | 20992 |
|---|---|
| Material | BPA-free plastic |
| Style | Slotted scoop |
| How it holds | Hand held, or over a small bowl |
| Size | 5 in long |
| Eggs at a time | Not stated |
| Care | Dishwasher safe |
| Guarantee | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits a cook who wants the job done for the occasional flan or meringue and sees no reason to give the tool more thought than that.
Skip it if you need your hands free. The listing shows no clip or hook, so one hand stays on the tool while the white runs through.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Very simple design
- BPA-free plastic
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Short, so it suits small bowls
- No shell-catching feature beyond the scoop
- Evidence is limited to roundups
3. Fox Run Stainless Steel Egg Yolk Separator – Steel That Nestles Over a Cup
If you prefer steel to plastic and you want it from an established housewares name, this is the one. Fox Run’s separator measures 6.75 by 1.75 by 1 inches and is made of stainless steel. The listing says it nestles over measuring cups and mixing bowls, so you can pour the egg in and let it work.
Fox Run is clear about the limit: it separates one egg at a time. That is honest, and it shapes how you use the tool. Separate each egg into a small cup first, then tip the white into the main bowl. That way one broken yolk ruins a single white and not the whole batch.
One caution belongs here. The only real side-by-side result we found is an April/May 2012 Cook’s Country report, as described by Baking Bites, and it rated a handheld Fox Run separator as not recommended because it was very slow compared with separating eggs by hand. The post gives no model number, so we cannot say which Fox Run it was, and nothing ties that result to this stainless tool. Treat it as a reason to keep expectations modest.
Why we like it
- Stainless steel, dishwasher and hand wash safe
- Nestles over cups and mixing bowls
- An established maker
- The listing is plain about the one-egg limit
Key specifications
| Model | 5793 |
|---|---|
| Material | Stainless steel |
| Style | Slotted cradle |
| How it holds | Nestles over cups and bowls |
| Size | 6.75 x 1.75 x 1 in |
| Eggs at a time | 1 |
| Care | Dishwasher or hand wash |
| Guarantee | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits a baker who wants one metal tool that will outlast a plastic one and who works one egg at a time anyway, which is good practice for meringue.
Skip it if you want speed through a large batch. Fox Run says one egg at a time, and a long coil model handles a run of eggs with less fuss.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Stainless construction
- Hands-free over a cup
- Easy cleanup in the dishwasher
Cons
- One egg at a time
- A Fox Run separator, model not named, was rated not recommended in a 2012 report
- Size suits cups and small bowls best
4. Peleg Design YolkFish Silicone Egg Separator – Lifts a Yolk Out of the Bowl
The YolkFish works differently from everything else on this page. You crack the egg into a bowl first, squeeze the silicone fish, touch its lips to the yolk and let go. Suction draws the yolk in, and a second squeeze puts it down wherever you want it. It looks like a toy, but the method has a real advantage, because you can go back for a yolk after the egg is already in the bowl.
Peleg Design describes the silicone as food safe and dishwasher safe. Bustle’s roundup says it requires cracking the egg into a bowl first and calls it fun to use, though that piece does not claim any trial of its own. Another roundup in our search lists occasional yolk breakage as a drawback, which fits the method: suction asks the yolk to pass through a soft opening.
Cleaning needs a little thought. A squeeze tool holds raw egg inside it, and raw egg is the one thing you do not want left in a kitchen tool. Pull it through the dishwasher or wash it with hot, soapy water right after you finish, and check inside before you put it away.
Why we like it
- Works after the egg is already in a bowl
- Food-safe silicone, per the maker
- Dishwasher safe
- Puts each yolk exactly where you want it
Key specifications
| Model | PE801 |
|---|---|
| Material | Food-safe silicone |
| Style | Squeeze suction |
| How it holds | Hand held |
| Size | Not stated |
| Eggs at a time | 1 yolk per squeeze |
| Care | Dishwasher safe |
| Guarantee | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits someone who cracks several eggs into a bowl and then wants the yolks out, and it makes a good gift for a baker who already owns the plain tools.
Skip it if you dislike washing the inside of a soft tool. A flat slotted separator rinses clean in seconds.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Yolks can be lifted out afterward
- No draining wait
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Occasional yolk breakage reported
- Raw egg sits inside between squeezes
- Needs a free hand for the squeeze
5. Peleg Design Daisy Plastic Egg Separator – Sits on a Cup Like a Flower
The Daisy is the second Peleg pick, and it works in a completely different way from the fish. It is a flat plastic flower that sits on top of a cup. You crack the egg over it, the yolk settles in the center and the white runs down into the cup below.
The listing calls it food-safe, BPA-free plastic and gives its size as 4.3 by 4.3 by 1.3 inches, though the size field shows a larger figure in centimeters that looks like the packaging. BestReviews lists it as a top pick and says it prevents spills and keeps shell fragments out of the whites. Its one stated limit is the cup, which can be no wider than 4 inches.
Sous Vide Guy adds a fair complaint, that the outer rim could be wider, and it files the tool under design more than function. That matches what you see. You are buying a cheerful gadget that happens to do the job, and for a small gift or a baking-themed present, that is reason enough.
Why we like it
- Sits on a cup with no hands needed
- Named a top pick by BestReviews
- BPA-free plastic, per the listing
- Backed by a no-questions guarantee from Peleg Design
Key specifications
| Model | 45797 |
|---|---|
| Material | BPA-free plastic |
| Style | Flat flower with center cup |
| How it holds | Rests on a cup up to 4 in wide |
| Size | 4.3 x 4.3 x 1.3 in |
| Eggs at a time | Not stated |
| Care | Easy to clean, per the listing |
| Guarantee | No-questions promise from Peleg Design |
Why we recommend it
It suits gift buyers and bakers who separate an egg or two over a measuring cup, and who like a kitchen tool with some personality.
Skip it if you work over a wide mixing bowl. BestReviews says the cup under it can be no wider than 4 inches.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Hands-free on a cup
- Keeps shell out of the whites, per BestReviews
- A good small gift
Cons
- Limited to narrow cups
- The outer rim could be wider, per Sous Vide Guy
- The listing gives two different sizes
6. CAMKYDE Stainless Steel Spiral Egg Separator – Long Handle and a Coil Basket
CAMKYDE is one of the two Amazon-first brands on this page, and it is here for a reason. BestReviews lists it as a top pick, and the design solves the problem the short tools have. A long handle reaches across a mixing bowl, a hook steadies it on the far side and a spiral coil holds the yolk while the white falls between the turns.
The listing says the tool is food-grade stainless steel with a soft rubber grip on the handle, and that the spring coil’s spacing keeps the yolk in place. It claims the white filters instantly, which we would read as seller language. BestReviews gives a more measured account: it calls the tool easy to clean and compact, measures it at 10 inches and notes that some users reported yolk slipping through with certain eggs.
That slipping is the honest cost of the coil. Older eggs tend to have thinner whites and looser yolks, so go gently and use one egg at a time over a cup if the whites are headed for meringue. CAMKYDE does not state a dishwasher rating on this listing, and a coil has plenty of turns to trap egg, so give it a proper wash under hot, soapy water.
Why we like it
- Long handle spans a wide bowl
- Hook steadies it on the rim
- Named a top pick by BestReviews
- Hangs up for storage
Key specifications
| Model | CK-1101 |
|---|---|
| Material | Food-grade stainless steel, rubber-wrapped handle |
| Style | Spiral coil |
| How it holds | Hook on the bowl rim |
| Size | 10 in long, per BestReviews |
| Eggs at a time | Not stated |
| Care | Easy to clean; dishwasher use not stated |
| Guarantee | Satisfaction promise from the seller |
Why we recommend it
It suits a baker working over a large mixing bowl who wants the speed of an open coil and is willing to go a little slower when the eggs are not fresh.
Skip it if you want an established maker behind the tool. This is an Amazon-first brand, and the OXO or Fox Run is the safer choice on that count.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Reaches across big bowls
- Quick to drain, per the listing
- Metal body with a soft grip
Cons
- Some users report yolk slipping through
- Amazon-first brand
- Dishwasher use is not stated
7. Ytuomzi Stainless Steel Egg Separator – Slotted Steel at a Compact Length
This is the second Amazon-first brand here, and it earns its spot with outside coverage. BestReviews lists a Ytuomzi separator as a top pick and calls it easiest to use, and Bustle includes one in its roundup. Both describe a slotted stainless tool with hooked handles that rest on the bowl.
The listing says you hang it on the side of the bowl and crack the egg into the slots, and it gives food-grade stainless steel and dishwasher-safe construction. It claims a three-second separation, which we would not take as a promise. The size is where it differs from the CAMKYDE: Bustle measures it at almost 7 inches and says it suits smaller bowls only, while BestReviews says it is too short for large mixing bowls.
The listing also says its metal body is safer than plastic separators. No authority we found backs that up, so ignore it and choose on fit and feel. There are several similar Ytuomzi listings, and the reviewers do not name an ASIN, so we cannot promise they looked at this exact one. What matters is that the brand and the design match their descriptions.
Why we like it
- Dishwasher-safe stainless steel, per the listing
- Rests on the bowl with its hooks
- Covered by both BestReviews and Bustle
- Compact for storage
Key specifications
| Model | FDQ01 |
|---|---|
| Material | Food-grade stainless steel |
| Style | Slotted cradle |
| How it holds | Hook on the bowl rim |
| Size | Almost 7 in long, per Bustle |
| Eggs at a time | Not stated |
| Care | Dishwasher safe |
| Guarantee | Not stated |
Why we recommend it
It suits a cook who wants steel, works over a small bowl or a measuring cup and likes a tool that fits in a crowded drawer.
Skip it if your usual bowl is large. Both reviewers say it is too short to rest across one, so you would end up holding it.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Stainless and dishwasher safe
- Small enough to store easily
- Independent coverage from two roundups
Cons
- Too short for large bowls
- Amazon-first brand
- The listing’s safety and speed claims are unsupported
How to choose an egg separator
Start with the style. There are three common designs. A slotted cup or scoop holds the yolk while the white drains. A coil does the same with wider gaps, so it drains faster but lets a loose yolk slip more easily. A suction tool lifts the yolk out of a bowl after the egg is cracked. Only the last one rescues eggs that are already mixed in the bowl.
Check the fit against your bowl. This decides more than anything else. A 5-inch or 7-inch tool will not reach across a big mixing bowl, and the Peleg Daisy needs a cup no wider than 4 inches. If you bake in a glass mixing bowl, measure it before you buy.
Decide whether your hands should be free. A tool that clips or hooks on leaves you free to crack the next egg. A plain scoop keeps one hand busy. For two eggs that is fine, but for ten it gets old.
Think about cleaning. Every one of these tools touches raw egg, so the easy-to-clean choice is the sensible one. Flat slots rinse quickly. Coils have many turns to reach into, and a squeeze tool has an inside you cannot see.
Be realistic about speed. Cook’s Country’s report, as described by Baking Bites, found that most separators did not speed up the job. Some had slots too small for the white to pass, and others had slots too large to hold the yolk. If you have good hands and fresh eggs, you may do just as well without a tool. The reason to buy one is control, and keeping the shell out of the bowl.
Keeping raw egg out of the wrong places
The FDA’s egg safety guidance says to wash hands, utensils, equipment and work surfaces with hot, soapy water before and after they touch raw eggs. A separator is exactly that sort of utensil, so wash it as soon as you finish and do not leave it in the sink with egg drying on it.
The same guidance says that for dishes where eggs stay raw or undercooked when served, you should use pasteurized egg products or Salmonella-treated shell eggs. It names Caesar dressing and homemade ice cream as examples. Keep that in mind if your separated whites are going into something that will not be cooked.
Separate each egg over a small cup and not over the main bowl. It is a habit worth keeping for a reason that has nothing to do with safety: one broken yolk spoils only that one white.
How we chose these seven separators
We looked at what a working kitchen cares about in a small tool: whether it does the job, whether it fits the bowl, what touches the egg and how easily it comes clean. We have not used these products ourselves. Each pick rests on the Amazon listing, the maker’s statements and the outside reviews named above: BestReviews, Bustle, Sous Vide Guy and the Baking Bites report on Cook’s Country.
That outside evidence is thin, and we would rather say so. The Cook’s Country report dates from 2012, and its two best-rated models, from Wilton and Kuhn Rikon, did not turn up on Amazon when we looked. The roundups are affiliate pages like this one. BestReviews says it researches and evaluates products, while the Bustle piece relies on buyer comments and Sous Vide Guy does not say the separators were tried.
Because this tool touches raw food, we did not use a thin brand without outside coverage to fill out the list. That ruled out the OTOTO Dunk N’ Egg, a neat design for which we found no independent review, and the many no-name steel listings. Ceramic novelty chicks are out too: they come from thin brands, and a glazed surface would need a maker’s lead-free statement. CAMKYDE and Ytuomzi are the only two Amazon-first brands here, and both stayed because reviewers covered them. Each pick was in stock when we wrote this. We also searched the CPSC recall database for each maker and found no recall naming these tools.
Egg separator questions, answered
Is an egg separator better than using the shell?
It is gentler on the yolk, because no sharp shell edge is involved, and it keeps your fingers out of the egg. It is not always faster. Cook’s Country found that most models did not beat a practiced hand, according to the Baking Bites report.
Why do my egg whites not whip after separating?
A trace of yolk or grease is the usual cause. Separate each egg over a small cup, so that a broken yolk never reaches the main bowl, and whip in a clean, dry bowl. For the whipping itself, see our hand mixer guide.
Do fresh or older eggs separate better?
Fresh eggs have firmer yolks and thicker whites, so the yolk holds together better but the white drains more slowly. Older eggs drain faster, though the yolk is more likely to break or slip through a coil.
Can an egg separator go in the dishwasher?
Most of them can. OXO, Chef Craft, Fox Run, Peleg Design’s YolkFish and Ytuomzi all say so on their listings. CAMKYDE does not state it, and the Peleg Daisy listing only says it is easy to clean, so hand wash those two unless the packaging says otherwise.
What is the difference between an egg separator and a fat separator?
They share a name and little else. An egg separator splits yolks from whites. A fat separator is a pitcher that pours the juices from a roast out from under the fat.
The separator we would keep in the drawer
Related guide: Egg separator alternative.
Start with the OXO. It handles the crack, the separation and the shell, and it sits on the bowl without your help. Add the YolkFish only if you like the idea of lifting yolks out after the fact. For more small egg tools, see our egg slicer guide and our egg rings. And if you would rather leave the flan to someone else, see the Julia’s menu and call to order at (346) 546-8283.